Thermal management plays a central role in the functionality, safety, and durability of any vehicle—whether it’s driven by a gasoline-powered internal combustion engine (ICE) or a battery-powered electric drivetrain. With the rapid rise in electric vehicle (EV) adoption, understanding the critical contrasts between EV thermal management and traditional ICE cooling systems has become essential for consumers, automotive engineers, and technology enthusiasts alike.
From managing intense battery heat to maximising passenger comfort across all weather conditions, EVs and ICE vehicles approach thermal challenges with distinctly different strategies. This article explores these differences in detail—highlighting why EVs need advanced thermal management, the unique technologies involved, the challenges each system faces, and where the automotive future is headed.
Why Vehicles Need Thermal Management
The Heat Problem in Engines and Batteries
Both ICE and EV platforms generate significant amounts of heat:
- ICE Vehicles: Produce heat through fuel combustion, friction from moving parts, transmissions, and exhaust systems.
- EVs: Generate heat via batteries (especially during fast charging and high demand), inverters, motors, power electronics, and energy recovery systems.
Too much heat can lead to engine failure, battery degradation, loss of power, or even fires. Thus, thermal management ensures optimal temperatures are maintained, safeguarding performance and prolonging critical component life.
Read Also: Coimbatore EV Charging Guide – EV Post Locations & Fast Charging Points
Fundamentals of ICE Cooling Systems
Conventional ICE vehicles depend on cooling systems designed to control the engine’s temperature, which can exceed hundreds of degrees Celsius during operation. The essential components and steps include:
Key Components
- Radiator: Disperses heat from coolant liquid.
- Coolant (water/glycol mix): Circulates within the engine block, absorbing heat.
- Water Pump: Drives coolant flow.
- Thermostat: Regulates coolant temperature and flow direction.
- Fan: Assists heat dissipation from the radiator.
- Oil Cooler: Sometimes used to manage engine or transmission oil temperatures.
Process
- Coolant absorbs engine heat, cycling through the engine block.
- Heat is transferred to the radiator, where airflow cools the liquid.
- Cooled liquid returns to the engine for another cycle.
Additional Cooling Demands
- Transmission cooling for automatic gearboxes
- Turbocharger intercoolers in modern performance vehicles
Traditional ICE cooling systems are robust, well-understood, and relatively standardised due to decades of refinement.
Fundamentals of EV Thermal Management Systems
Unlike combustion engines, electric cars require a multi-faceted approach to thermal management. They must regulate the temperature of batteries, electric motors, power electronics, cabin climate, and even charging components.
Key Components
- Battery Cooling/Heating System: Controls cell temperature during charging/discharging, especially in fast charge cycles.
- Thermal Management Unit: Centralized control, often integrating all vehicle heat sources and sinks.
- Heat Exchangers/Chillers: Transfer heat between batteries and outside environment.
- Coolant Loops: Fluid channels (typically glycol-based) for heat transfer, but often highly modular.
- Pumps and Valves: Control the direction and pressure of coolant flow.
- Refrigerant Heat Pumps: Used for both cabin heating/cooling and battery thermal regulation.
- Sensors & Control Software: Advanced management via sensors, AI, and predictive algorithms.
Battery-Centric Design
Batteries are highly sensitive to temperature—operating best between roughly 15°C to 35°C. Overheating can cause rapid cell ageing or thermal runaway, while extreme cold reduces range and charging capability. Thus, modern EVs focus much of their thermal system design on maintaining ideal battery temperatures under all conditions.
How ICE and EV Cooling Systems Compare
Heat Source Differences
- ICE: Primary heat originates from internal combustion and friction from mechanical parts.
- EV: Major heat sources are batteries, power electronics, and high-speed electric motors.
Cooling Medium
- ICE: Primarily uses water-glycol coolant and air cooling through radiators and fans.
- EV: Uses advanced coolants (sometimes dielectric fluids) and often integrates refrigerant-based heat pumps for efficient multi-zone cooling and heating.
Technical Complexity
- ICE: More mechanical components (belts, pumps, hoses), with simple thermostatic regulation.
- EV: Fewer moving parts, but systems are often more integrated—combining cabin, electronics, and battery cooling in a single module managed by intelligent software.
Energy Efficiency
- ICE: Draws engine power to run pumps and fans, creating parasitic losses.
- EV: Must minimize energy use for thermal management to preserve driving range; thus, efficiency is paramount and managed precisely by advanced control units.
Environmental Demands
- ICE: Well suited to wide temperature extremes, but emissions control can be affected by temperature.
- EV: Needs cabin comfort and battery management to be effective in both hot and cold climates, or range and charging performance will plummet in harsh conditions.
SCREEN – 1
SCREEN – 2
Innovations in EV Thermal Management (2025)
Modular and Integrated Systems
Modern EV thermal systems often feature modular designs combining several cooling loops into a single efficient unit. Integration reduces system weight, cost, and space—and enhances reliability.
Heat Pumps
Heat pumps in EVs can both heat and cool the cabin or battery, often by scavenging waste heat from the drive components. They improve winter range by up to 20% compared to old-fashioned resistive heating.
Advanced Coolants and Direct Cooling
Liquid cooling has become the industry standard for EV batteries. Some next-generation systems now pursue direct cooling—where cells are immersed in non-conductive coolants for even, rapid heat removal. This is analogous to some advances in high-performance computing cooling.
AI and Real-Time Control
Smart software, powered by sensors and sometimes AI, can predict thermal needs and adapt the system dynamically. This predictive strategy prevents overheating or overcooling before it happens, increasing reliability and efficiency.
Two-Phase and Passive Solutions
Innovations like phase change materials (PCMs) and two-phase cooling (using coolant evaporation/condensation cycles) are gaining traction for peak load conditions, especially in fast charging and performance EVs.
Advantages and Drawbacks
EV Thermal Management: Pros and Cons
Advantages:
- High integration lowers overall system weight and part count.
- Efficient energy usage increases vehicle range and performance in all climates.
- Adaptive systems respond smartly to changing conditions with minimal user intervention.
Drawbacks:
- More complexity in software and sensor systems requires sophisticated maintenance.
- Direct cooling solutions add cost due to specialty coolants and system design.
- Extreme cold or heat can still stress EV systems, leading to temporary range limitations.
- High repair costs if system fails outside of warranty.
ICE Cooling Systems: Pros and Cons
Advantages:
- Robust and proven after decades of use.
- Simple mechanical fixes are often possible without deep technical expertise.
- Typically less expensive to build and maintain.
Drawbacks:
- Limited to engine cooling; poor adaptability for electronics or batteries.
- Parasitic losses reduce fuel efficiency.
- Doesn’t support rapid waste heat harvesting for cabin or energy saving.
- Higher emissions affected by temperature swings.
Read Also: Chennai EV Charging Guide – EV Post Locations & Fast Charging Points
Looking to the Future: Electrification’s Demands
Automakers are investing heavily in advanced thermal management for EVs—driven by demand for longer range, faster charging, and high performance in all weather conditions. Next-generation solutions using AI, nanomaterials, and multi-functional coolants will likely become universal, further differentiating EVs from their legacy ICE predecessors.
As electrification becomes the new normal, ICE cooling systems will fade into the background, replaced by smart, integrated, efficient, and environmentally conscious thermal management strategies—making transportation safer, greener, and smarter for all.
About The Author
