United States: EV Insurance by State – Where Are Rates Cheaper?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are surging in popularity across the United States, driven by consumers’ growing environmental awareness and state incentives promoting clean energy transportation. While EVs offer numerous benefits including lower emissions and reduced fuel costs, a key factor consumers often overlook is insurance. EV insurance tends to be more expensive than traditional gas-powered cars due to factors like higher repair costs, expensive battery replacements, and specialized maintenance. However, insurance rates vary widely across states, influenced by local regulations, risk factors, and market competition.

This article examines EV insurance cost differences state by state across the U.S. to highlight where EV owners can find cheaper insurance rates and what factors drive regional disparities. Understanding these variations can help potential and current EV drivers make smarter choices for coverage and budgeting.

Why Are EV Insurance Rates Higher?

On average, insuring an electric vehicle costs about $44 more per month, or roughly 49% more annually, than a comparable gasoline vehicle. This higher cost arises mainly from the expensive technology involved. For example, batteries or specialized parts cost significantly more to repair or replace, increasing insurer payouts. Additionally, EV models like Tesla’s frequently command higher premiums because they are costly to fix and have advanced safety systems that affect claims processes.

Still, insurance rates are not uniform nationally and can differ dramatically depending on the state of residence.

Read Also: Do EV Batteries Lose Capacity Over Time?

The States with the Cheapest EV Insurance Rates

Looking at average annual insurance premiums, the states offering the lowest EV insurance rates tend to be those with:

• Lower population densities resulting in less traffic congestion and fewer accidents
• Fewer natural disaster risks such as flooding or hurricanes
• Competitive insurance markets with multiple providers offering discounts

According to recent data, some of the states with the cheapest EV insurance rates include:

• Maine: Average annual cost for full coverage is about $1,175, making it the state with the lowest car insurance rates overall.
• New Hampshire: Around $1,265 annually for full coverage.
• Vermont: Approximately $1,319 annually.
• Ohio: At roughly $1,417 annually, Ohio is among the more affordable options for insuring an EV.
• Idaho: Close to $1,428 in average annual premiums.
• Indiana and Illinois: Both hover around $1,515 and $1,532 respectively.

These states generally combine lower risk factors and good regulatory environments, helping to keep EV insurance affordable.

States Where EV Insurance Is More Expensive

On the other hand, some states have considerably higher EV insurance premiums due to:

• Greater urban density and traffic congestion (leading to more claims)
• Higher frequency of natural disasters or harsh weather conditions
• Increased rates of uninsured drivers or higher crime rates
• Stricter minimum coverage requirements driving up base costs

Examples of states with higher full coverage EV insurance premiums include:

• Louisiana: Highest cost with an average premium around $2,883 annually.
• Florida: Close behind at about $2,694 per year, reflecting risks from hurricanes and traffic density.
• California: High EV adoption does not necessarily mean lower costs as California’s premiums average $2,416 due to urban traffic and repair costs.
• Colorado: Roughly $2,337 annually, affected by urban Denver and costly vehicle repairs.
• South Dakota: Around $2,280 annually.

In these states, drivers pay a premium for both geographic risk and sometimes for state-mandated coverage minimums.

Monthly Cost Examples for EV Insurance by State

Breaking down the numbers further into monthly costs for an average EV:

State	Monthly Average EV Insurance Cost
Hawaii	$121
Idaho	$122
Illinois	$158
Indiana	$147
Alabama	$195
California	$217
Colorado	$210
Florida	$313
Louisiana	$295

Hawaii leads as one of the cheapest by monthly cost, at roughly $121, while Florida and Louisiana remain the most expensive states for EV insurance.

Factors Driving State Rate Differences for EV Insurance

A variety of factors contribute to these disparities:

• Repair and Replacement Costs: States with higher labor and parts costs naturally see higher premiums. Additionally, regions prone to flooding or hurricanes (Florida, Louisiana) increase risk for battery damage.
• Traffic and Population Density: Higher accident rates in big cities like Los Angeles or Miami push up premiums.
• State Insurance Regulations: States that require higher minimum liability coverage will see higher base premiums. States with strong consumer protections may also drive up insurance prices by requiring more coverage options.
• Presence of Incentives: Some states encourage EV adoption with rebates and tax credit programs, indirectly helping reduce total ownership costs. However, these incentives do not always translate to insurance discounts.
• Competition Among Providers: Markets with more insurance carriers generally have more competitive rates and better discount availability.

Read Also: How Industry Leaders Are Revolutionizing EV Battery Tech

Tips for EV Owners to Find Cheaper Insurance

• Shop Around Frequently: Rates can vary substantially among providers even within the same state.
• Ask About EV Discounts: More insurers are offering green vehicle discounts or special rates for EVs.
• Consider Higher Deductibles: If financially feasible, a higher deductible can lower monthly premiums.
• Bundle Coverage: Combining auto insurance with home or renters insurance can yield discounts.
• Maintain a Clean Driving Record: Safe driving remains one of the most impactful ways to lower insurance costs.

Conclusion

While EV insurance is generally more costly than gasoline vehicle insurance in the U.S., where a driver lives makes a significant difference. States like Maine, New Hampshire, and Vermont provide affordable EV insurance options, while Louisiana, Florida, and California tend to have some of the highest premium rates. Understanding state-wise differences can empower EV owners to make informed decisions about coverage and budget for the total cost of ownership more accurately.

As EV adoption continues to accelerate and insurance markets adapt, more competitive and innovative EV insurance options are expected, potentially reducing costs for eco-conscious drivers in every state.

About The Author